COLUMBUS, Ohio — The woman convicted of aggravated murder in the death of a 5-year-old was sentenced to spend at least the next 29 years in prison on Thursday.
The sentencing hearing started with a surprising request from Maye, who has admitted to killing Darnell Taylor in February of 2024. Ahead of her sentencing, she tried to fire her attorney.
“He represent me like he was a prosecutor instead of defending me,” she told the judge.
The judge asked follow-up questions to understand her thinking, given that she’d confessed to the crime.
Ultimately, Maye decided to keep her attorney, and the hearing proceeded with members of Darnell’s family giving victim impact statements. An advocate began by reading a letter from Darnel's biological mother, Latitia Taylor.
“My one and only child, Darnell, was murdered by someone I thought was nice and who I could trust to love, protect and care for my son,” she said.
Taylor told the judge she regretted the decision that landed Darnell in foster care. But she regretted trusting Maye even more.
“I beg the court that Pammy Maye never see daylight outside of prison walls,” she read from a prepared statement.
WATCH MORE from the trial:
RELATED: Trial underway for Ohio woman accused of killing foster son, leaving body in storm drain
During the trial, the prosecution said Maye killed Darnell because he snuck peanut butter crackers into bed for a snack. She suffocated him, put his body in a plastic bag and left him in a Franklin County sewer. Maye then fled to Northeast Ohio, where she was arrested and ultimately led police to the child’s body.
Darnell’s grandmother, Shanda McGee, also addressed the court.
“The thought of Pammy Maye is like a painful migraine,” she said. “To hear her name is like a nagging toothache.”
McGee made an emotional plea for Maye to spend the rest of her life in prison, calling her actions evil, wicked, heartless and cruel.
“My grandson Darnell did not deserve to be murdered by the hands of another human being who turned out to be the monster in the dark closet that he was always scared of,” McGee said.
At the end of the hearing, all that was left was for Maye to speak.
“The family was right,” she told the judge. As she struggled to speak, her defense attorney leaned in and encouraged her to apologize.
“He was a loving child,” she said. “He loved people and stuff. He liked having fun and stuff. He didn’t deserve it.”
The judge decided she did appear to show genuine remorse. He sentenced her to 25 years to life for aggravated murder, and one year each for four additional counts, including tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse.
The judge said Maye will be 80 years old by the time she is eligible for parole, adding that he'd never seen a parole board grant early release on the first attempt.